Every Friday right before I light Shabbat candles I turn off my cellphone. With my phone off I am finally ready to welcome in the Shabbat- which literally means “rest.” Shabbat is “יום מנוחה”- the day of rest. I am never truly at rest when my phone is nearby. What work email just came in to which I need to respond? Did my daughter send me a photo on whatsapp from her trip? Is there news from Israel? My brain is never at rest. (I must say that Tefillah or when I am teaching, when my phone is away, can be partial rest). And, I am an adult with some self-control and not very techy- so I actually still engage in non-technological contact with others. I cannot imagine what it is like for our children who have phones.
Actually, I can imagine, as if you read my last week’s column you would know that I literally live the middle school life daily in my role. That is why I congratulate and thank all of you who have signed the K-6 pledge “I will delay giving my child a smartphone and social media until after 8th grade.” And, for those of you who signed the 7th and 8th grade pledge: “I will delay giving my child social media until after 8th grade”- thank you! (I appreciate the fact that many of you have already given your children phones before this pledge went out, and it is hard to turn back the clock). We all know that you have given your children some menucha and they don’t have to wait for Shabbat to get that. Thank you.
I know the research results are intuitive, but I will share them anyway. In the Journal of Developmental Psychology, a 2023 research review: “Longitudinal and Daily Associations between Adolescent Self-Control and Digital Technology Use” shares that:
Adolescents with poorer self-control may be less skilled in effortfully avoiding the development of habitual digital technology behaviors. Some users catch themselves reaching for devices without full awareness (Gomes et al., 2021) or mindlessly scroll social media (Baym et al., 2020)... may be especially vulnerable to these tendencies, and may be less likely to employ habit-disrupting strategies like removing visual and auditory cues, including keeping one’s smartphone out of sight or deleting specific apps (Nguyen, 2021).
In 1926 Rabbi Shraga Feivel Mendlowitz advertised the opening of a new town in Long Island called Sabbathville. In those days it was not so simple to keep Shabbos and he came up with the idea of a totally Shabbos- observant community. And, while there were ads for the community in all the Jewish newspapers, it appears that the community never came to fruition. But, every so often I wish I lived in Sabbathville. Or more like “tech Sabbathville.”
This town of Sabbathville reminded me of the Technology Shabbat I had come across when I saw a link to a video by Tiffany Shalin on Technology Shabbat. She describes an entire movement, popular even among non-Jews, to choose one day to disconnect from technology and reconnect with the people in our lives. It is an opportunity to stop “phubbing,” or snubbing a person in favor of your phone. G-d was the first initiator of a Shabbat where He stopped creating and rested. G-d even paused at the end of each day to take the time to look around and say כי טוב- it was good. So too when we take a Tech Shabbat we mimic G-d and stop to enjoy and appreciate all that we have created throughout the hectic week. It provides us with the opportunity to rejuvenate, recharge and rewire our frazzled brains. We, religious Jews, are lucky enough to have this day built into our halachic system. But, perhaps we need extended Tech Sabbaths.
As we approach Chag HaPesach- the chag when we go מעבדות לחירות- from slavery to freedom, I am truly worried that our children who have phones are slaves to their phones. And, the truth is, we are too. I recently came across some questions that if you answer yes to 5 out of 7, you are in a fact a slave to your phone:
Do you look at your phone within a minute or two from hearing a beep or a buzz?
Do you look at your phone (for no other reason than checking who made contact) more than once every 20 minutes?
Do you reply to messages even while in the company of someone else?
Do you take your phone with you everywhere you go – even to the bathroom?
Do you often fall asleep with your phone in your hand?
Do you regularly use your phone after turning off the lights for bedtime?
Do you get anxious if you hear a beep or a buzz on your phone, but force yourself not to look at it right away?
Are your Apps set up so that you can see who is online at any given time?
Would you rather spend an hour communicating with friends on your phone than go walking with a friend while leaving your phone at home?
And, again, to repeat that which we already know, as Adina Soclof shares in her article “Practical Advice in Managing Your Child’s Use of Technology," we are seeing that our children are enslaved and “addicted” to their technology. They are constantly switching between devices. We see extreme reactions when we take technology away. Impatience, irritability, restlessness, inability to focus. We see sleep disturbances and increased social difficulties/drama.
A research study by Common Sense Media reinforces these findings. 80% of teens said they checked their phones hourly and 72% said they felt the need to immediately respond to texts and social networking messages. 36% of parents said they argued with their children daily about device use. 77% of parents feel their children get distracted by their devices and do not pay attention when they are together, at least a few times each week.
Ironically, the limits that we place on our children and on ourselves are what free us from enslavement to our phones/devices.
Similarly, it says that one might think that the limitations of the Torah are stifling and limit our freedom. It is actually the opposite, as it says in Avot 6:2:
וְאוֹמֵר (שמות לב) וְהַלֻּחֹת מַעֲשֵׂה אֱלֹהִים הֵמָּה וְהַמִּכְתָּב מִכְתַּב אֱלֹקים הוּא חָרוּת עַל הַלֻּחֹת, אַל תִּקְרָא חָרוּת אֶלָּא חֵרוּת, שֶׁאֵין לְךָ בֶן חוֹרִין אֶלָּא מִי שֶׁעוֹסֵק בְּתַלְמוּד תּוֹרָה.
And it says, “And the tablets were the work of God, and the writing was the writing of God, graven upon the tablets” (Exodus 32:16). Read not haruth [‘graven’] but heruth [‘freedom’]. For there is no free man but one that occupies himself with the study of the Torah.
The limitations placed on us by the Torah provides us with freedom from the Yetzer Hara and the inclination to do the wrong thing.
Going back to Tiffany Shalin for a moment, she recommends a full 24 hours each week disconnected. She is not religious, so for her Tech Shabbat (which she happened to choose as Saturday), she realized she needed items to take the place of her technology. She recommends remembering to install a landline, and to get a radio or record player, a watch and a pen! (Remember those?)
Speaking of a landline, I want to tell you about the wonderful landline we installed outside the school office since students are not allowed to bring phones to school. If a student forgets his sneakers, needs food for dinner before practice, or wants to know who is driving him home, all he needs to do is use the students’ landline. It has been absolutely life-changing for our school! And, I know some parents have shared with me that they plan on installing landlines in their homes as well.
And, as Tiffany Shalin mentions, we do need something to take the place of technology use during the week. I recently attended Yeshiva University’s Stomp Out the Stigma night, where students share real-life mental health struggles with the audience. One young man shared how when he was struggling he became addicted to his cellphone, even at times watching Netflix on Shabbat as it was the only way to soothe himself. Instead of our children seeking out technology to self-soothe (which I often see) we need to give them other strategies and even other activities to do in place of technology use. For some it’s sports or music. At the Stomp Out The Stigma event they handed out the newsletter of the Active Minds student organization that organized the evening. One student wrote about knitting and crocheting as an example of an activity that has been shown as a source of soothing and relaxing, and a way to quiet one’s mind.
(I think I have already made my point, but while I am on the topic of technology, I want to add a conversation I had with a parent this week (not in sixth grade) who is frustrated that her son’s (who does not have social media) friends all have Snapchat…or at least that is what her son is saying. “Everyone has Snapchat.” It’s hard to know if that is true or not. I know I have discussed this before, but Snapchat is really not safe for our children. Photos and videos appear to disappear after they are viewed, but anyone can take a screenshot- and if that is done with a different device there will not be an alert. And, we as parents cannot monitor “snaps” due to their disappearance. Snapchat is a platform for bullying and irresponsible/inappropriate posting).
Pesach- זמן חירותינו- the time of our freedom- is upon us. Let us keep in mind how to free ourselves and our children from the enslavement of technology. And, as we proclaim in the haggadah, הָשַּׁתָּא עַבְדֵי, לְשָׁנָה הַבָּאָה בְּנֵי חוֹרִין- Now we are slaves; next year we shall be free!